As an Amazon Associate, Smart Cooks earns from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are shown on Amazon and may change.
You baked the perfect pie for Thanksgiving. Now it has to survive a car ride, a crowded entryway, and a kitchen counter full of other dishes. A pie carrier protects the crust and the topping, and the right one also keeps a cream pie cold or a pumpkin pie from sliding into the side of the dish.
Here is what to look for and six carriers worth considering.
How to Choose a Pie Carrier
Measure your pie dish, not the pie
Most carriers fit a 9- to 10-inch pie plate. Deep-dish and fluted ceramic dishes often have wide rims that measure 11 inches or more. Measure rim to rim before you buy.
Height for toppings
Meringue, whipped cream, and lattice crusts need headroom. Look for at least 3 inches of interior height for topped pies.
Single, stacked, or multi-pack
If you bring two pies every year, a carrier with a shelf (two levels) or a multi-pack saves trips. Multi-packs of plastic containers also work well for giving pies away, so you don’t have to chase your good dish afterward.
Insulated vs plain
For cream, custard, or ice-box pies on long drives, an insulated tote with an ice pack keeps things safe. For fruit pies, a rigid plastic carrier is enough.
Locking lid and handle
A lid that snaps on at several points and a sturdy handle matter more than looks. Carry it flat, not swinging.
From My Kitchen
The worst pie trip I remember was a pumpkin pie in a loosely covered dish on the floor of the back seat. One hard brake later, the filling had slid to one side and the foil was stuck to it. Since then I chill custard pies thoroughly before travel (a cold filling sets firm and moves less) and put the carrier on a towel in the trunk or on the floor, never on a seat. A good carrier helps, but a well-chilled pie is half the battle.
6 Pie Carriers Worth Considering
Best for two pies: Essaware Pie SAFE Travel & Storage Container
A tall, rigid carrier with an adjustable shelf, so it can hold two pies, a tall cake, or cupcakes. A great fit for families who bring more than one dessert.
Good for
- Two pies on one trip
- Cakes and cupcakes
Watch out for
- Bulky to store the rest of the year
Best for giving pies away: Evelots Pie Container with Lid, 2-Pack
Clear BPA-free pie containers sized for standard pie plates. Hand one over with the pie and you don’t have to worry about getting it back.
Good for
- Bake sales and gifting
- Standard 9-inch pies
Watch out for
- Not insulated
Best multi-pack: Evelots Pie Container with Lid, 4-Pack
The same clear containers in a four-pack, for big baking days.
Good for
- Holiday baking marathons
- Leftover storage
Watch out for
- Lids are simple snap-on, so carry it flat
Best for cream and custard pies: MIAOJIE Round Insulated Casserole Carrier (12″)
An insulated round tote that holds a pie dish or a casserole and keeps it cold (or warm) on longer drives.
Good for
- Cream, custard, and ice-box pies
- Casseroles for potlucks
Watch out for
- Soft sides: put the pie in a rigid dish
Best insulated 2-pack: Arineng 2-Pack Pie Containers with Insulated Bags
Rigid pie containers paired with insulated bags and non-slip pads.
Good for
- Long drives
- Two pies kept cold
Watch out for
- More pieces to store
Budget 3-pack: Youngever 3-Pack Pie Containers
Simple plastic pie keepers for storage and short trips.
Good for
- Leftovers in the fridge
- Short drives
Watch out for
- Lighter-weight plastic
Quick Comparison
| Carrier | Type | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Essaware Pie SAFE | Rigid, 2-level | Two pies or tall cakes |
| Evelots 2-pack / 4-pack | Clear rigid | Gifting, bake sales |
| MIAOJIE | Insulated tote | Cream and custard pies |
| Arineng | Rigid + insulated bags | Long drives |
| Youngever | Light plastic | Storage, short trips |
Still choosing the pie itself? See our picks for pie dishes for flaky crusts and rolling pins for pie crust.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a deep-dish pie fit in a standard pie carrier?
Sometimes not. Deep-dish pies are taller and their dishes often have wider rims. Measure both the rim diameter and the total height with toppings.
How long can a pumpkin pie be out of the fridge?
Custard-based pies like pumpkin should be refrigerated and generally not left at room temperature for more than about two hours. Use an insulated carrier with an ice pack for longer trips.
Can I freeze pies in these containers?
Many plastic pie containers are freezer safe, but check the maker’s guidance. Wrap the pie in plastic first to prevent freezer burn.
